Off the plot and into the woods

Dec 19, 2024

A quarter of a century ago I began planting woodland trees on a recently acquired 7 acre field about 5 miles from the main plot. Although the field’s purchase coincided with the turn of the century this was not a personal ‘millennium project’, neither was there a burning ambition or grand mission. Indeed there wasn’t really even a plan other than a wish to plant some trees to enhance the local landscape and ecology and make a minuscule contribution to combating the destruction of the planet.

The field lies in a rather drab area of lowland Yorkshire. The most prominent nearby landmarks are giant pylons and an intensive turkey unit. Apart from a tallish hedgerow punctuated by two mature oaks bordering the lane, and another hedgerow at the far end, the field was effectively bare when we bought it. Today it is still no rural idyll, but it is transformed. Nearly 3 of the 7 acres are now planted with woodland trees on the west, north and east boundaries. On the south side is a new hedgerow and in the centre pasture and a 70 tree orchard. Some of the thousand or so forest trees planted in batches over several winters now stand over fifteen metres tall. The change that’s been achieved is rewarding, but at times establishing the woodland has been challenging. Although we never thought it was just a matter of plonking the trees in the ground and sitting back while they grew, some of the issues that arose were tricky and unexpected. It underlines that getting trees in the ground is only the first, and in many respects the easiest, step in woodland planting. Caring for the young trees in the years that follow is just as important and, in some respects, more worrisome and difficult.

Soil type is a key consideration when considering which tree species to plant in any new woodland. The field sits on very heavy clay prone to winter waterlogging, the kind of soil that squelches as you tread on it after any wet spell. We therefore knew that only species able to cope with heavy and sticky soil were likely to succeed. Trees such as beech or sweet chestnut that hate wet feet or claggy gunge were not an option. As oak and ash were the predominant trees in the surrounding farmland we decided to make these core species. But to increase diversity birch, hornbeam, field maple, crab apple, bird and wild cherry, wild pear and wild service were added to the mix. Plus, in what turned out to be a very wise decision given the soil’s wetness, white and black poplar, white and crack willow, aspen and alder were also included. With the exception of the alder, it is these damp lovers that are now the tallest. In part this is because these are naturally fast growers, but it does also reflect the conditions. The number one lesson when planting any trees is to select those suitable for the soil type.

Another factor that affected how fast the trees grew was the planting pattern. Apart from choosing damp lovers for the swampier spots, we tended to plant fairly randomly. Species, especially the oak and ash, were either intermingled or planted in small same species clusters. It’s now clear this was a mistake. For example, where ash and oak were mixed the former has generally grown more strongly. In some spots the oaks have been shaded out completely, in others they have become straggly. Only in places where there are no faster growing neighbours has oak grown away well. It’s now clear that we should have planted more in species blocks and been aware that some trees, for example the rapidly growing willows and poplars, boosted by the wet conditions, would overshadow and suppress their neighbours.

Tall ​growing ​white ​poplars (Left) ​towering ​above ​other ​species

Because problems were anticipated with rabbits and deer all saplings were protected at planting by 1.2m tube tree shelters. This was very effective with virtually no losses due to rabbit bark nibbling or deer grazing. However, removing the tubes as the trees grew was a chore. The tubes were perforated to make them split and fall away as the trunk girth swelled. In the vast majority of cases however this didn’t happen. As a result the tubes had to be cut using a knife, a painstaking process if scoring of the trunk was to be avoided. Worse still as the tubes were removed so our pile of discarded ones grew. The tubes were marketed as biodegradable and recyclable, but in practice neither seems to be the case. Today most of the tubes are still largely intact and showing no signs of breaking down. And recycling appears to be possible at just a few locations, many of which accept only large consignments or charge a hefty fee. We have been able to reuse some of the tubes on new plantings by re-joining the cut edges with cable ties, but still have hundreds for disposal. It’s good to see more awareness that littering the countryside with plastic tree guards is environmentally damaging. Several big planters, such as the Woodland Trust, are now either enclosing blocks of new trees in wire enclosures or planting without any protection but at greater densities to offset loss. If I was to plant at scale again, I’d be using one of these options.

The menace of grey squirrels was another unforeseen issue. With limited tree cover in the immediate vicinity we assumed there would be few squirrels. It didn’t take long, however, before they moved in. At first, apart from joining voles in denuding the young hazels of nuts before they were fully ripe, they were an amusing distraction. Then it became apparent that they enjoyed gnawing the bark of some of the trees, especially field maple. A good number of these have been so seriously chewed that the large branches have died back. More recently oaks have also come under attack. A significant number now have large branches ring barked resulting in death of limbs that break in high winds to dangle, like swords of Damocles, in the canopy.

Grey squirrel damage: Areas of stripped bark (Left) and a ring-barked lodged branch (Upper Centre)

There have been other problems, mostly minor, for example roe deer have badly frayed the trunks of a few trees through head and antler rubbing (shed roe deer antlers have identified the culprits!). Caterpillars munching leaves have occasionally caused concern. Partial defoliation of many young oaks one spring was especially alarming, but the trees soon reshot and continued to grow. However, now major tree loss looms large. Over the last couple of years it’s become evident that ash (Chalara) dieback was beginning to gain a foothold. So far we seemed to have largely escaped, possibly because the trees avoided summer drought stress on the water retentive soil but this summer, despite the deluges, its presence has become obvious. On at least half the ash, many have branches bare of leaves and it seems inevitable that most of the ash, probably about 20% of the total trees planted, will succumb. At present I’m debating what to do. Should there be selective felling of the most severely affected trees to try to control, or at least delay, infection? Or should we simply let the disease run its course hoping that some will show resistance and survive? If you’ve experience of dealing with ash dieback your views would be appreciated.

The challenges of planting and nurturing woodland are not to be under-estimated. It’s certainly not a case of randomly chucking in the trees and leaving them to their own devices. Planning and preparation are required from the start and regular maintenance necessary as the trees grow. For those contemplating planting woodland there are lots of sources of advice. The Woodland Trust offers guidance in its very comprehensive Woodland Creation Guide as does the Forestry Commission (separate versions are available for Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland) If you want something in print then a handy up to date guide is Antony Mason’s Tree Planting: How to Create a Woodland.

We hope you’ve enjoyed reading Mr Fluttergrub’s findings. Do you have experience of growing trees? What have you learned from the experience? Do let us know. We’d love to have your points of view so we can add them to this article for the benefit of the WWOOF UK community and beyond. Send your comments to: editor@wwoof.org.uk

What does it really mean to host a WWOOFer?

What does it really mean to host a WWOOFer?

You don't need a picture perfect farm or a lifetime of experience. But you do need something you're happy to share. If you've spent a few years growing food, there is a good chance you've learned things you barely think about anymore. When to plant, how to make...

I Dig This Life!

I Dig This Life!

Earlier this year, we asked the WWOOF community to get creative... We were looking for a design to feature on our new merchandise, something that reflected the people, places and experiences that make WWOOFing what it is. We weren't entirely sure what we'd get back,...

You don’t need land. You need curiosity.

You don’t need land. You need curiosity.

You don't need a garden, an allotment, or a few acres in the countryside to start learning how to grow food. Sometimes, all you need is a bit of curiosity and someone willing to show you the ropes. There's something rather satisfying about the idea of growing your own...